Search form

menu menu
  • Daily & Weekly newsletters
  • Buy & download The Bulletin
  • Comment on our articles

Colruyt loses case against minimum tobacco prices

12:23 22/09/2016

Supermarket chain Colruyt’s challenge against minimum prices for tobacco has been turned down by the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg, which said that the minimum price regulation was not in breach of EU law.

Colruyt filed the challenge after it was fined for selling cigarettes and other tobacco products at prices lower than the tax-stamp attached to every packet. The company was also accused of illegal advertising, by offering quantity discounts and sales on tobacco products on certain dates, and by offering discounts to youth organisations.

The supermarket argued that the price of an article cannot be considered advertising, pointing to a 2011 directive that allowed the fixing of a maximum price but said nothing about a minimum price. Minimum prices were in breach of the principle of free movement of goods and fair competition, the chain argued.

The federal government argued that minimum prices were a tool for controlling the sale of tobacco, by including a disincentive in the amount of excise duty charged.

In an opinion in April, the advocate-general indicated that the Belgian law was not in breach of EU rules. While such opinions are not binding on the full court, they are followed more often than not.

Photo: Virginie Lefour/BELGA

Written by Alan Hope

Comments

Mikek1300gt

I quite agree with a minimum price in this case, what bothers me is the effective maximum price. You know, like cigs were a loaf of bread?

Sep 22, 2016 13:11