Search form

menu menu
  • Daily & Weekly newsletters
  • Buy & download The Bulletin
  • Comment on our articles

Child bike helmets failing to protect, says Test-Achats

22:09 04/09/2017

A joint investigation by French and Belgian consumer protection groups has concluded that children's cycle helmets do not offer enough protection - even though all of the models tested met EU safety standards.

Test-Achats and its French equivalent UFC-Que Choisir put 12 of the most commonly sold helmets to the test using a new method developed by university researchers in Strasbourg.

The tests are based on computer modelling of the skull which aims to give a better picture of the impact of vertical and horizontal shocks on a child's developing brain.

The least effective of the 12 helmets, according to the two consumer groups, presented an 80% risk of brain damage in the tested conditions. In the best model, the risk was 30%.

"All of the helmets we tested have received European approval," said Test-Achats spokesman Jean-Philippe Ducart. "We believe the assessment criteria are insufficient and that both the European Commission and the Belgian authorities must review them. Manufacturers are happy to comply with standards that are no longer suitable, as our tests show. A new, more realistic test methodology is needed."

Consumer affairs minister Kris Peeters said: "The safety of cyclists - and especially children - is important. If it appears that European safety standards for bicycle helmets are flawed, then these will be changed."