- Daily & Weekly newsletters
- Buy & download The Bulletin
- Comment on our articles
Airlines must repay €19 million in illegal state aid
The federal government will reclaim more than €19 million in total from Brussels Airlines, TUI (formerly Jetair) and Thomas Cook – after subsidies they were given for using Brussels Airport was ruled illegal state aid. For Brussels Airlines alone, the sum comes to €16.8 million.
The money was initially granted as a contribution to security infrastructure costs for airlines that handled an annual minimum of 400,000 departing passengers. The aid was contested by Ryanair and Vueling as state aid and thus unfair competition; they filed a complaint with the European Commission, which agreed.
The “security grants” were in fact intended to help airlines compete with low-cost competitors like Ryanair, which registers its employees in Ireland, where social security charges are much lower. As Ryanair’s headquarters are in Ireland, this is legal to do even for employees who do not live or work in Ireland.
The subsidies amounted to €19 million a year for three years, from 2014-2016. It was not paid out in 2015 or 2016 because of the complaint procedure. Brussels Airlines set the funding aside because “it was generally known that the scheme the government had set up […] would be challenged by Europe,” a spokesperson said.
The airlines said they would not contest the ruling, but would wait for the government to come forward with an alternative system to meet its promises regarding unfair competition.
Photo courtesy Brussels Airlines








